2020 Shortlist Profiles
This year there were 43 entrants for the Seamus Heaney award for the best debut collection published in the UK and Ireland, and as always the judges were deeply impressed with the creativity on display. Nick Laird, chair of the judges panel said of this year's submissions:
'There was immense diversity in tone and subject matter, and it was a struggle to narrow the candidates down to only five books. The shortlist we’ve chosen represents not just accomplishment but also potential.
Each book on the shortlist is ambitious enough to find, amid the deafening static of real life, a space to communicate in. We were put in mind of John Hewitt’s prescription: I do not pitch my voice/ that every phrase be heard / by those who have no choice: / their quality of mind / must be withdrawn and still, / as moth that answers moth / across a roaring hill. Any one of these books would be a worthy winner, and all are worth your time.'
Read the judges comments for each of these exceptional collections, below.

"Mary Jean Chan’s Flèche is a skillful debut, replete with details of negotiating family life as a queer daughter, and life in her adopted home of England. Chan represented Hong Kong in the rarefied world of competitive fencing, and the title refers to a fencing technique – as well as punning on flesh. Taking in Chinese history and culture, alive to how language can be weaponized or form a refuge, these are loving poems of linguistic dexterity, of Chan trying to reconcile the many strands that meet in her".
- Nick Laird, chair of the judging panel
Winner of the 2019 Costa Book Award for Poetry
Shortlisted for the 2020 Dylan Thomas Prize
Shortlisted for the 2020 John Pollard Foundation International Poetry Prize
Shortlisted for the 2020 JhaLak Prize
2019 Book of the Year in The Guardian, The Irish Times and The White Review
Flèche (the French word for ‘arrow’) is an offensive technique commonly used in fencing, a sport of Mary Jean Chan’s young adult years, when she competed locally and internationally for her home city, Hong Kong. This cross-linguistic pun presents the queer, non-white body as both vulnerable (‘flesh’) and weaponised (‘flèche’), and evokes the difficulties of reconciling one’s need for safety alongside the desire to shed one’s protective armour in order to fully embrace the world.
Central to the collection is the figure of the poet’s mother, whose fragmented memories of political turmoil in twentieth-century China are sensitively threaded through the book in an eight-part poetic sequence, combined with recollections from Chan’s childhood. As complex themes of multilingualism, queerness, psychoanalysis and cultural history emerge, so too does a richly imagined personal, maternal and national biography. The result is a series of poems that feel urgent and true, dazzling and devastating by turns.
Mary Jean Chan was born and raised in Hong Kong. She is lecturer in Creative Writing (Poetry) at Oxford Brookes University and lives in London.
Chan has been twice shortlisted for the Forward Prize for Best Single Poem and received an Eric Gregory Award in 2019. She has written poetry reviews and op-eds for the Guardian Review, and her literary criticism has been published in the Journal of American Studies and the Journal of British and Irish Innovative Poetry. In Spring 2020, Chan served as guest co-editor at The Poetry Review.

"Isabel Galleymore’s Significant Other is full of contenders for the title role of this gorgeous book: here are human partners, animal correlatives such as barnacles and tarantulas and owls, but also the imagination itself. One’s most significant other might be the mutable self, a cloud who can take the shape of anything. Galleymore’s poems have a conviction and a restraint rare among debut work".
- Nick Laird, chair of the judging panel
The Telegraph's Poetry Book of the Month March 2019
A Telegraph Book of the Year 2019


"Tom Sastry’s A Man’s House Catches Fire is a terrific debut dedicated to the idea of metaphysical transformation, to fairytales and nightmares, to the power of humor to leaven the most leaden situation. Honest and consistently surprising, Sastry’s debut is interested in despair, and how it might be – if not defeated – at least held off a little longer."
- Nick Laird, chair of the judging panel
What to do when everything goes up in flames? Summon up Tom Sastry’s poems, with all their elegant, satirical and hurt-quenching power: here are nightmares and fairytales, museums full of regret, misenchantments and magic for dark times.
Whilst the accelerants of complicity and violence seep from these exacting poems, Sastry’s wit and stoicism slake the bonfire of modern troubles. They defiantly ask us: why do “the great marquees of England” stand empty? How old is your heart? Why aren’t we listening to the sea, and what it has to say? Funny, marvellously frank and often courageous, A Man’s House is on Fire urges us to take a long hard look into the flames and avert the disasters of the heart, home and nations that threaten to befall us all.
This much anticipated debut collection by poet Tom Sastry follows on from his pamphlet Complicity, selected by Carol Ann Duffy for the Poetry Business Laureate’s Choice and awarded the Poetry Book Society Pamphlet Choice.
“Tom Sastry’s poems stare down the ridiculousness of the world we live in, and offer us ways to carry on in spite of it. These are poems of bright wit and astonishing vulnerability, with one eye always on the future. A Man’s House Catches Fire gives us the simultaneous pain and joy of being a human being; reminds us it is marvellous / that it still hurts.”
– Suzannah Evans
Tom Sastry was chosen by Carol Ann Duffy as one of the 2016 Laureate's Choice poets. His resulting pamphlet Complicity was a Poetry School Book of the Year and a Poetry Book Society pamphlet choice. He is the co-editor with Suzannah Evans of Everything That Can Happen, a poetry anthology about the future published by The Emma Press. This is his first full collection. An accomplished reader and performer, Tom has a growing reputation as a spoken word artist. A book of his performance poems will be published by Burning Eye Books in 2020.

'Laura Scott’s So Many Rooms is a confident and intricate collection dealing with relationships and memory. Cognizant of all the angles, alive to the smallest damage, to the bruises left on petals by the rain, Scott is a master of the slant take, the delicate phrasing. Her images both clarify and darken the matter at hand. In Scott’s world, poems are ‘like fish / swimming inside you, / waiting for someone / to tap the glass.”'
- Nick Laird, chair of the judging panel
The Guardian's Poetry Book of the Month August 2019
So Many Rooms, the debut collection from Geoffrey Dearmer Prize-winning poet Laura Scott, moves with its own lyric strangeness, opening up different rooms and also different worlds.
'There can be no doubt at all that this is an exceptional piece of work. Scott has the capacity to capture drama in a small number of words, neatly arranged. Her poetry, in this way, is the quintessence of poetry. Her clarity, concision and quiet ambiguity are yardsticks against which I find myself measuring other poets. Its confidence and its consistency both suggest a poet who has arrived. She offers a comprehensive vision. We are watching a poet composing at the height of her powers. It's not even September yet, but I suspect it might be my poetry book of the year.'
- Joe Darlington, Manchester Review of Books
'I couldn't put it down and have kept returning to these poems, drawn in - and on - by their beauty and clarity. Her lyricism is like shot silk - it ripples with light.'
- Kate Kellaway, The Guardian
'These are intimate poems, grounded, yet dreamlike, revealing the beauty, gravity and power at the core of the everyday. They're all the more compelling because it's as if the poems are allowed to make their own discoveries with the poet knowing exactly when to step back, and when and how to intervene.'
- Moniza Alvi
'So Many Rooms is beguiling and lyrically persuasive. Scott's fine formal control and her mesmerising shifts of imagery underpin poems of sensual intelligence, thoughtfulness and poetic beauty.'
- Sasha Dugdale

"Lucy Wadham’s Fold is wonderful - cool and sharp and charming at the same time. Here are poems of domestic life keenly and generously observed: Wadham has an expert eye for the ramifying detail. Her work is celebratory and elegiac at the same time, taking ‘spots of time’ and scraping meaning from the incidental. These are poems of a rare sensibility."
- Nick Laird, chair of the judging panel
Better known as a novelist and as author of the best-selling The Secret Life of France (Faber & Faber), Lucy Wadham brings her knowledge of France, and her experiences as an outsider, to her debut poetry collection. From the remote Cévennes mountains, where “a man and a woman sit bent / over their soup, her thoughts / silenced for years, rising like smoke” (Dissent), via Croatia, Italy and Scotland, with “The small boy with his square / of blue crochet, his broad brogue: / I’m gonnae call ma babby Finn MacCool” (Crossing Mull), Lucy’s skills as an observer strike at the heart of what it means to be human.
“Observant and imaginative, these poems stake out the world of experience and feelings with enough confidence to make the reader believe the poet must have been writing them for twenty years, not five. They have a wonderful sense of drama, and above all know how to begin and how to stop. The best poems here have a sharpness and brilliance that transcends the private material that can sometimes be powerful for the writer but not for anyone else. Rich in a sympathetic sensibility, they are outward-looking as well as inwardly analytical. And they manage to be funny as well.”
- John Fuller
Lucy Wadham was born in London and has lived for over 30 years in France. She is the author of three novels, Lost, Castro's Dream and Greater Love (all Faber) and two memoirs: the bestselling The Secret Life of France (Faber) and Heads and Straights (Penguin). She has spent most of her life in Paris and in the Cévennes mountains, where she teaches a creative writing course twice a year and also works as a writing tutor.
She has four children, has written for newspapers, theatre, film and opera, and is currently working on several TV scripts. Fold is her first poetry collection.