Queen's researchers find people in NI want the UK to stay in the customs union and single market
In-depth analysis of public attitudes to Brexit in Northern Ireland, by researchers from Queen’s University and funded by the ESRC's UK in a Changing Europe initiative, find people want the UK to stay in the customs union and single market.
The research report, entitled 'Northern Ireland and the UK’s Exit from the EU: What do people think?' found:
- There is substantial and intense opposition in Northern Ireland to possible North-South border checks between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland and also to possible East-West border checks between Northern Ireland and Great Britain
- One in five Catholics find the possible use of cameras at the North-South border ‘almost impossible to accept’ and almost one in 10 Catholics (9 per cent) would support cameras being vandalized.
- There are strong expectations that protests against either North-South or East-West border checks would quickly deteriorate into violence.
- There is substantial support for a Brexit that would largely eliminate the need for any North-South or East-West border checks, namely for the UK as a whole to remain in the customs union and single market.
- 61 per cent of the population are in favour of the UK as a whole remaining in the customs union and single market and support for this option is 61 per cent among Catholics and 62 per cent among Protestants.
- Catholics are much more likely to support a united Ireland if there is a ‘hard’ exit in which the UK leaves both the customs union and single market.
- 28 per cent of Catholics would vote for a united Ireland if the UK changed its mind and remained in the EU while 53 per cent of Catholics would vote for a united Ireland if there was a ‘hard’ exit in which the UK left the customs union and single market.
- The proportion of people in Northern Ireland wanting to Remain has risen since the 2016 referendum as more people have become aware of the possible costs of leaving the EU.
- 69 per cent would vote Remain if there was another referendum compared to the 56 per cent who voted Remain at the time of the referendum
Professor John Garry, Principal Investigator on the project and Professor of Political Behaviour from the School of History, Anthropology, Philosophy and Politics at Queen’s, said: “We find Catholics and Protestants most prefer the option that would avoid the need for any new barriers on borders. Either in the Irish Sea or across Ireland. They want the UK as a whole to stay in the customs union and single market.”
Professor Brendan O’Leary, Lauder Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania and visiting World Leading Researcher at Queen’s, noted: “Our results show that if there was another referendum, people in Northern Ireland would vote more strongly to remain in the EU. The proportion wanting to Remain has risen since the 2016 referendum as more people have become aware of the possible costs and inconveniences of leaving the EU, as citizens and as employees or employers.”
Professor Garry and Professor O’Leary emphasise that the least preferred option is a hard exit, in which the entire UK leaves the single market and the customs union (only 15 per cent of people support this option), necessitating new barriers on the land border.
The research finds that many citizens are strongly opposed to any form of border checks between Northern Ireland and the Republic and fear that any such barriers would provoke protests and possibly worse. One middle-aged male Catholic Remain voter said: “The cameras will have to be about 300 feet in the air, and even then… You will get certain people take the law unto themselves and [will] cut these things down. … It would have to be the softest hardest border. Military checkpoint is a ‘No No.’ Cameras, that would be a ‘No, No, ‘as well…”
The research team observed that Catholics were more likely than Protestants to support the option that would leave Northern Ireland in the customs union and the single market, while Great Britain left both.
“However, what may surprise people,” says Professor Garry “is the extent to which Catholics oppose all borders within these islands.” They reject having barriers at ports and airports, as well as having them across Ireland.
The option of Great Britain exiting the customs union and the single market, while Northern Ireland remains in both, is the so-called 'backstop option'. It is in the draft withdrawal agreement between the UK and EU-27, if no other way can be found to avoid a new hard border on Ireland.
In discussions about possible protests against any border checks between Northern Ireland and Great Britain, one male Protestant Leave voter, aged between 35 and 44, highlighted potential reaction: “Flag protests again… and it could escalate if they were forced into a hard border [in the Irish Sea]… Non-violent to start off with, then it would be blocking roads.”
Strikingly, the results also show that Catholics are much more likely to support a united Ireland if there is a ‘hard exit’ in which the UK leaves both the customs union and single market.
To read the full report, please visit: https://www.qub.ac.uk/sites/brexitni/BrexitandtheBorder/Report/Filetoupload,820734,en.pdf