This Guide is intended for use by postgraduate research students who wish to appeal a decision of their School Postgraduate Research Committee on student progression, assessment and award.
You should read this Guide in conjunction with the Academic Appeals Regulations (Research Degree Programmes) Where there is any doubt the Regulations take precedence over these guidelines.
You may appeal against decisions relating to the following:
You may not appeal against the academic judgement of an examining or decision-making body. Academic judgement relates to the expertise of the examiners within the subject area, and their judgements on whether or not the work that was produced in the thesis was original, at the forefront of the discipline, and was of the standard required for the research programme. It is a judgement made about a matter where only the opinion of an academic expert will suffice.
Stage 1 – Appeal to the Faculty Student Research Appeals Committee (FSRAC)
You may appeal on grounds to the Faculty Student Research Appeals Committee (FSRAC) by submitting an FSRAC Appeal Form to Academic Affairs, Level 6, Administration Building, Queen’s University, Belfast, BT7 1NN or by email to email@example.com. You must complete all sections of the Form. You must submit the Appeal Form and any supporting evidence to Academic Affairs within 10 working days of the date of the notification of the decision on your progression, assessment and award which you wish to challenge.
Academic Affairs will acknowledge receipt of your appeal and will send it to the Head of your School for a response.
For each ground cited you must give details of how your appeal meets the grounds and provide evidence of how this has impacted on your studies.
Ground 1: New evidence has become available which could not have been provided to the School (evidence which was withheld from the School will not normally constitute new evidence).
You should consider the following:
Ground 2: There has been a procedural irregularity which has had a demonstrable impact on the progress/assessment/award outcome.
You should include the following:
Ground 3: There is evidence of inadequate assessment on the part of one or more examiners.
You should include the following:
Please note the FSRAC cannot make judgement on the academic content of your thesis.
Ground 4: There is evidence of inadequate supervision. This refers not to the academic judgement of supervisors regarding the quality of your work, but rather to the adherence to University regulations, procedures and codes of practice for the supervision of postgraduate research students. You will be expected to show that you took action at the earliest possible stage to deal with any alleged supervisory problems, or to explain why you did not take such action.
You should include the following information:
Once you have established that you have grounds for an appeal, it is strongly recommended that you seek advice and assistance on preparing your appeal. The Students’ Union will be able to assist you with the appeal form and a representative will also be able to accompany you to the Committee hearing.
Your appeal should be succinct; the use of bullet points, rather than a lenghty narrative, may help you to structure your appeal. Normally, your appeal should be no longer than four A4 pages and you should, where possible, try to limit the number of pages of appendices to no more than 50. However, it is understood that this may not always be possible.
As the FSRAC will consider your appeal on written evidence only, it is essential that you provide all the relevant information and supporting evidence to the FSRAC by the appeal deadline.
The following are examples of supporting documentation the Committee may consider as appropriate evidence:
On receipt of an appeal to FSRAC, Academic Affairs will acknowledge receipt of your appeal and refer the matter to the Head of your School (or nominee) for a response.
The School will provide a response to Academic Affairs, normally within 10 working days.
The FSRAC will meet to consider your appeal and the School response.
Your appeal (and any supporting evidence submitted by you) and the School response (and any supporting evidence) will be considered by the FSRAC. The decision on your appeal will be taken on the paperwork alone. Neither you, nor a representative from the School will be invited to attend a meeting.
The FSRAC may:
You will be notified of the decision of the FSRAC in writing by email to your Queen’s email account, normally within eight working days of the decision being taken. You will also receive a copy of all the paperwork considered by the FSRAC.
Stage 2 - Appeal to the Central Student Research Appeals Committee (CSRAC)
If you are dissatisfied with the decision of the FSRAC, you may appeal to the CSRAC by submitting a CSRAC Appeal Form to Academic Affairs within 10 working days of the written notification of the decision of the FSRAC.
The CSRAC will comprise a Pro-Vice-Chancellor (PVC) (or nominee) (Chair) and three Directors of Research or senior academic colleagues from across the University (normally one from each Faculty). You will have the right to attend the meeting of the CSRAC to present your case.
You may appeal on the following grounds:
Ground 1: New evidence has become available which could not have been provided to the FSRAC (evidence withheld from the FSRAC will not normally constitute new evidence).
You should consider whether the “new evidence” could have been disclosed to the FSRAC and, if so, what prevented you from informing the FSRAC of this evidence sooner.
Ground 2: There has been a procedural irregularity by the FSRAC which has had a demonstrable impact on the outcome.
You should include the following:
i. Details of the procedural irregularity, making reference to the appropriate regulation, procedure or process.
ii. Details on how the procedural irregularity affected the decision of the FSRAC.
You should include the following information, where appropriate:
You will be sent a formal invitation to the CSRAC which will provide at least five working days' notice of the date, time and venue of the CSRAC meeting.
You must confirm whether or not you intend to attend the meeting. If you fail to confirm whether or not you wish to attend your CSRAC meeting by the stated deadline, your appeal will be withdrawn and the decision of the FSRAC will stand.
Given the current uncertainly caused by the global coronavirus pandemic, you may be asked to attend the CSRAC meeting virtually using the Microsoft Teams software (free to download for all QUB staff and students), Skype or teleconference, rather than in person. The University will continue to adhere to the guidance issued by the Public Health Agency and details of safety precautions in place for your CSRAC meeting will be detailed within your invitation letter.
If you are invited to an 'in person' CSRAC but wish to attend virtually instead, it may be possible to arrangeyour attendance by Microsoft Teams.
Whilst it is not compulsory for you to attend this meeting, it is recommended that you attend your CSRAC meeting in order to present your appeal to the CSRAC panel. If you do not wish to attend the CSRAC meeting and would like your appeal heard on paperwork alone, you must inform the Appeals and Complaints Team by the deadline stated in your CSRAC invitation.
If you confirm your attendance and then fail to attend your CSRAC meeting without a good reason, the CSRAC may consider your case in your absence on the basis of the paperwork alone. It is your responsibility to establish good cause for your absence from the CSRAC. If you establish ‘good cause’ to the satisfaction of the Committee, then the meeting may be re-scheduled unless you have indicated that you wish the case to be considered by the CSRAC in your absence.
You have the right to be accompanied at any stage in the proceedings by a registered student of the University (which shall include a Students’ Union Sabbatical Officer), a member of staff of the University, or University Chaplaincy. The role is one of support, not representation.
If you consider that you have a disability or condition, you should advise Academic Affairs (firstname.lastname@example.org) when submitting your appeal or as soon as possible so that the appropriate reasonable adjustments can be put in place to help you engage as fully as possible with the appeals process. This may entail a consultation with Disability Services.
The CSRAC may:
If the appeal has been upheld on the ground of inadequate supervision, the CSRAC shall recommend to the School that one or more supervisors be replaced.
The decision of the CSRAC is final; there is no further internal right of appeal. However, if you are aggrieved by the decision of the CSRAC, you may submit a complaint to the Northern Ireland Public Services Ombudsman within six months of notification of the University’s final decision.
All appeals will be treated with the appropriate level of confidentiality, with information being released only to those who need to see it.
In accordance with the Academic Appeals Regulations (Research Degree Programmes), all information submitted by you and by the School will be shared with the members of the Committees. You, the Chair of the FSRAC (or nominee) and/or the School will be sent copies of the information sent to the members of the CSRAC. You should not include in your appeal any information which you do not wish to be shared. You should also ensure that your appeal documentation does not contain any information relating to third parties; the names or any information by which a third party could be identified should be redacted, unless the third party consents to the information being shared. The information must also comply with the University’s Policy on Data Protection.
You should be careful not to make unsubstantiated or defamatory allegations or comments about other persons. The University may require any such comments to be deleted before accepting your appeal.
Queen's University Belfast is committed to Equality, Diversity and Inclusion.
For more information please read our Equality and Diversity Policy.
Queen's University Belfast is registered with the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland NIC101788
VAT registration number: GB 254 7995 11